Accolades
| NCAA Division III Player Of The Year (NSCAA) | ||||
| Name | Position | Year | ||
| Scott Deopere | Forward | 2000 | ||
| NCAA Division III All-America (NSCAA) | ||||
| Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Matt Boehnen | Midfielder | 2001 | Second | |
| Scott Deopere | Forward | 1999 | Second | |
| Forward | 2000 | First | ||
| Roberto Gutierrez | Midfielder | 1994 | Third | |
| Derek Kasten | Forward | 2003 | First | |
| Shane Lohr | Midfielder | 2003 | Third | |
NCAA Division III All-Region (NSCAA) |
||||
| Name | Position | Year | Region | Team |
| Jeremy Arens | Midfielder | 2000 | Midwest |
Second |
| Matt Boehnen | Midfielder | 2000 | Midwest |
First |
| Midfielder | 2001 | Central | First | |
| Jack Borski | Defender | 2008 | North Central | Second |
| Derek Christiansen | Goalkeeper | 2007 | North Central | First |
| Jason Cottone | Forward | 1994 | Midwest |
Third |
| Scott Deopere | Forward | 1999 | Midwest |
First |
| Forward | 2000 | Midwest |
First | |
| Ryan Dineen | Goalkeeper | 2003 | Central | First |
| Goalkeeper | 2004 | North Central | Second | |
| Andy Domer | Midfielder | 2006 | North Central | Third |
| Mark Foster | Forward | 2001 | Central |
Fourth |
| Shaun Gallagher | Defender | 2007 | North Central | First |
| Chad Govin | Midfielder | 1992 | Midwest |
First |
| Roberto Gutierrez | Midfielder | 1993 | Midwest |
Second |
| Midfielder | 1994 | Midwest |
First | |
| Midfielder | 1995 | Midwest |
First | |
| Brad Haga | Defender | 2001 | Central | First |
| Defender | 2002 | Central | Fourth | |
| Midfielder | 2003 | Central | Second | |
| Greg Henschel | Forward | 1993 | Midwest |
First |
| Forward | 1994 | Midwest |
First | |
| Joe Herkowski | Defender | 1999 | Midwest |
First |
| Will Howell | Midfielder | 2007 | North Central | Third |
| Midfielder | 2007 | North Central | Second | |
| Derek Kasten | Forward | 2002 | Central | First |
| Forward | 2003 | Central | First | |
| C.J. Lipinski | Defender | 2004 | North Central | Third |
| Defender | 2005 | North Central | Second | |
| Shane Lohr | Midfielder | 2002 | Central | Fourth |
| Midfielder | 2003 | Central | First | |
| Jon Loth | Forward | 1996 | Midwest |
Second |
| Dave Makovec | Midfielder | 2004 | North Central | Third |
| Ian Martin | Forward | 1988 | Mideast | Third |
| Dave Melum | Defender | 1996 | Midwest |
First |
| Alex Minten | Defender | 2007 | North Central | Second |
| Kevin Murphy | Forward | 2006 | North Central | Third |
| Ben Olson | Defender | 2004 | North Central | Second |
| Mark Pawlyshyn | Midfielder | 1989 | Mideast | Second |
| Midfielder | 1991 | Mideast | Second | |
| Rich Plier | Goalkeeper | 2000 | Midwest |
Third |
| Mitch Poppen | Goalkeeper | 1992 | Midwest |
Second |
| Goalkeeper | 1993 | Midwest |
First | |
| Robin Rameker | Goalkeeper | 1995 | Midwest |
Third |
| Goalkeeper | 1996 | Midwest |
First | |
| Pat Sorensen | Midfielder | 1993 | Midwest |
Third |
| Jeff Vanderpoel | Defender | 1997 | Midwest |
Third |
| Keith Zust | Midfielder | 1997 | Midwest |
First |
| NCAA Scholar All-America Team (NSCAA) | ||||
| Name | Year | |||
| C.J. Lipinski | 2005 | |||
| Shane Lohr | 2003 | |||
| NCAA Division III Coach Of The Year (NSCAA) | ||||
| Name | Year | |||
| Toby Bares | 1994 | |||
| NCAA Division III Region Coach Of The Year (NSCAA) | ||||
| Name | Year | Region | ||
| Toby Bares | 1994 | Central | ||
| 2000 | Central | |||
| 2003 | Central | |||