Conference Accolades
| All-WIAC | ||||
| Name | Position | Year | Team | |
| Paul Beach | Midfielder | 2009 | First | |
| Jack Borski | Defender | 2009 | First | |
| 2010 | First | |||
| Brandon Briones | Forward | 2009 | First | |
| Will Chaney | Defender | 2010 | First | |
| 2011 | First | |||
| Mason Eddy | Defender | 2009 | First | |
| Mike Franzen | Midfielder | 2010 | First | |
| Ryan Hanna | Forward | 2011 | Second | |
| Will Howell | Midfielder | 2009 | First | |
| Evan Maly | Midfielder | 2011 | Second | |
| Paul Marx | Defender | 2011 | Second | |
| Brian Miller | Forward | 2010 | First | |
| Garrett O'Brien | Forward | 2011 | First | |
| James Pike | Goalkeeper | 2010 | First | |
| 2011 | Second | |||
| Tim Stadler | Midfielder | 2010 | First | |
| 2011 | First | |||
| Tony Starnes | Forward | 2010 | First | |
| WIAC Scholar-Athlete Of The Year | ||||
| Name | Year | Name | Year | |
| Paul Beach | 2009 | Garrett O'Brien | 2011 | |
| Robin Rameker | 1995 | |||