National Accolades
| NCAA Division III Player Of The Year (NSCAA) | |||
| Name | Position | Year | |
| Scott Deopere | Forward | 2000 | |
| NCAA Division III All-America (NSCAA) | |||
| Name | Position | Year | Team |
| Matt Boehnen | Midfielder | 2001 | Second |
| Jack Borski | Defender | 2010 | Third |
| Scott Deopere | Forward | 1999 | Second |
| Forward | 2000 | First | |
| Roberto Gutierrez | Midfielder | 1994 | Third |
| Derek Kasten | Forward | 2003 | First |
| Shane Lohr | Midfielder | 2003 | Third |
| NCAA Division III All-America (D3soccer.com) | |||
| Name | Position | Year | Team |
| Jack Borski | Defender | 2010 | First |
| Will Chaney | Defender | 2010 | Second |
| Defender | 2011 | Third | |
| NCAA Division III Coach Of The Year (NSCAA) | |||
| Name | Year | ||
| Toby Bares | 1994 | ||