Accolades
| NCAA Division III All-America | |||
| Name | Weight Class | Year | Finish |
| Adam Dorner | 174 | 2007 | Eighth |
| Joel Dziedzic | 149 | 1999 | Eighth |
| Duane Fischer | 190 | 1986 | Third |
| Rick Gruber | 118 | 1981 | Fourth |
| 118 | 1982 | Second | |
| 118 | 1983 | Third | |
| 118 | 1984 | Fifth | |
| Bill Kahle | 167 | 1996 | Fourth |
| Sean McCarthy | 167 | 1982 | Second |
| Mike Meunier | 142 | 1994 | Seventh |
| Rich Tomaszewski | 142 | 1982 | Seventh |
| 142 | 1983 | Seventh | |
| NAIA Champion | |||
| Name | Weight Class | Year | |
| Rick DeMarais | 158 | 1975 | |
| NAIA All-America | |||
| Name | Weight Class | Year | Finish |
| Gary Ader | 150 | 1978 | Fourth |
| Rick DeMarais | 158 | 1975 | Champion |
| 158 | 1976 | Third | |
| Ron Dworak | 142 | 1974 | Third |
| Blaine Felsman | Heavyweight | 1977 | Fifth |
| Heavyweight | 1978 | Fourth | |
| Stan Kellenberger | 134 | 1979 | Fourth |
| Joel Stolzman | 134 | 1977 | Fifth |
| 142 | 1979 | Second | |
| WIAC Champion | |||
| Name | Weight Class | Year | |
| James Abbott | 126 | 1971 | |
| Tom Adams | 150 | 1971 | |
| Gary Ader | 142 | 1975 | |
| 150 | 1976 | ||
| 150 | 1978 | ||
| Dick Beattie | 134 | 1973 | |
| Tim Burns | 118 | 1980 | |
| Chris Campion | 167 | 1989 | |
| Dick Christian | 177 | 1967 | |
| Gordy Christian | 167 | 1968 | |
| Mike Coakley | 118 | 1976 | |
| Ron Dworak | 142 | 1972 | |
| 142 | 1974 | ||
| 150 | 1973 | ||
| Joel Dziedzic | 149 | 2001 | |
| Blaine Felsman | Heavyweight | 1977 | |
| Rod Figueroa | Heavyweight | 1988 | |
| Duane Fischer | 190 | 1984 | |
| 190 | 1985 | ||
| 190 | 1986 | ||
| Rick Gruber | 118 | 1981 | |
| 118 | 1982 | ||
| 118 | 1983 | ||
| 118 | 1984 | ||
| Stan Kellenberger | 134 | 1979 | |
| Frank Kinateder | 123 | 1969 | |
| Sean McCarthy | 167 | 1982 | |
| Mike Meunier | 142 | 1994 | |
| Dave Moon | 137 | 1968 | |
| Mark Mulqueen | 167 | 1972 | |
| 177 | 1970 | ||
| Tim Potratz | 126 | 1983 | |
| 126 | 1986 | ||
| Terry Stoll | 118 | 1978 | |
| Joel Stolzman | 134 | 1977 | |
| 134 | 1978 | ||
| 142 | 1979 | ||
| Rich Tomaszewski | 142 | 1982 | |
| 142 | 1983 | ||
| Nick Wenger | 165 | 1999 | |
| WIAC Scholar-Athlete Of The Year | |||
| Name | Year | ||
| Jeff Matczak | 1991 | ||
| WIAC Coach Of The Year | |||
| Name | Year | ||
| Nick Matiash | 2003 | ||
| Todd Yde | 1997 | ||